Become a Fan!
Login
Username:

Password:

Remember Me

Lost Password?

Register now!
Main Menu
Who's Online
224 user(s) are online (192 user(s) are browsing Forums)

more...
Guru Dictionary
Print in friendly format Send this term to a friend  HUD
HEADS UP DISPLAY. A DIGITAL PROJECTED DISPLAY ON INSIDE OF WINDSHIELD CONTAINING VEHICLE INFO SUCH AS SPEED, ENGINE TEMP, RPM, ETC. FOR DRIVER INFOR...
Supporting Vendors
Platinum
Mid America Motorworks
Mid America Motorworks FREE CATALOG


Gold
FIC 770-888-1662


Registered Vendors
Guru Friends
Supporting Banners

TIRERACK.com - Revolutionizing Tire Buying


Shop for Winter Tires Now!




Support This Site
(1) 2 3 »
 Register To Post

Josh Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
I'm going to try to keep this post to the point as best I can. I'll edit with updates as I go along with new information.

Everyone please give a big thanks to tpi421vette (Jim) owner/operator of Gearhedz Race Shop in Salt Lake City, UT. Without him, this would not have been possible.

This would not be possible without donations from members of the forum. Bogus has agreed to be responsible for all the donated money. Any that is not used will be divided and returned. If you want to donate, please send your donations via paypal to abbogus@yahoo.com

There has been some question as to whether or not I'm taking the forum for a ride and simply using the members generosity for personal gain. I don't think that is the case, but I'm biased towards myself so it's impossible for me to render an unbiased opinion. However, biased as it may be, my opinion is:

I'm using the TFS heads first and then swapping to the AFR heads. I plan to leave the AFR heads on the engine. If the TFS heads make more power (or have some other desirable characteristic) it is possible that I might swap back to the TFS heads. If that ends up being the case, then I will have personally gained from the forums donations, as I normally would have just bolted on the AFR heads and sold the TFS heads without ever installing them. Should that situation arise, I'm not sure how to proceed. I suppose the best thing to do is cross that bridge when the time comes. Other than that possible scenario, I don't see how I am gaining anything by funding the test via forum member donation.


The short version:

I am testing AFR 195 Competition port cylinder heads against TFS 195 heads on my 1991 vette. I'll post dyno sheets of both, time slips of both, flow data, combustion chamber CC, intake runner CC, and over all driving impressions. That's the short version. If you aren't interested in the technical details, skip to post #2.

The long version:

Engine is a 383 with the following parts:

TPIS miniram with 1205 size ports
Eagle cast steel crank
Eagle forged rods, 6 inch, h-beam
SRP forged flat top pistons, .015 below deck
Chromoly rings
Comp Cam XFI cam P/N CCA-08-467-08 (230/236, .576/.57, 113 LSA, 56 degrees of overlap)
The rest of the engine is stock or new stock replacement parts.

I'll be swapping between 2 sets of heads for the test:

TFS aluminum 195 CC heads, P/N TFS-30400006-CNC.
The heads have bee hive springs, 10 degree locks, and titanium retainers.
The heads have been lightly ported and decked by Lloyd Elliot.
Total retail for the heads with port work and upgraded springs is $2000.

Tech data on the heads, quoted from the shop that did the testing, is as follows:

Hi Josh,

They did arrive and I already have a bunch of information for you.

First off they are 100% ported. Not just a bowl cleanup like you had alluded to. Guides are narrowed and necked downed nicely and this head had been ported from one end to the other. I might add it was done by someone who looked like they knew what they were doing and had a very neat hand (the walls were straight and the overall execution was certainly above average). The porting might not have been as obvious to you because the heads were glass-beaded when they were freshened disguising some of the finish sandroll marks that are clearly evident when you look closely.

Finished intake port volume 205 cc’s

Intake Flow

.200 @ 140
.300 @ 200
.400 @ 245
.500 @ 274
.550 @ 280
.600 @ 282

Exhaust port finished volume 76 cc’s

.200 @ 108
.300 @ 144
.400 @ 176
.500 @ 190
.600 @ 204

Combustion chamber volume is very small @ 57 cc’s (just under actually like 56.8 actually)


AFR aluminum 195 CC heads competition ports, P/N AFR-1095. Nothing has been done to the heads, they will be bolted on as they come from AFR. Total retail for these heads is $2016.

Intake:

.200 = 157
.300 = 207
.400 = 257
.500 = 287
.550 = 292
.600 = 304

Exhaust:

.200 = 127
.300 = 178
.400 = 210
.500 = 229
.600 = 236

2/11/08

I picked up the engine from the builder today. I also picked up my TFS heads from the same machinist, he did a valve job and slightly decked/skimmed the heads. I shipped one TFS head to a shop out of state for flow testing, intake runner volume, and combustion chamber CC measurements. I will have the same shop test the AFR heads.

2/18/09

I got an E-mail from the shop that is testing the heads. The information is in on the TFS heads. I copied and pasted the information up where I talk about the TFS heads. The meat and potatoes is:

Finished intake port volume 205 cc’s

Intake Flow

.200 @ 140
.300 @ 200
.400 @ 245
.500 @ 274
.550 @ 280
.600 @ 282

Exhaust port finished volume 76 cc’s

.200 @ 108
.300 @ 144
.400 @ 176
.500 @ 190
.600 @ 204

Combustion chamber volume is very small @ 57 cc’s.

I also got the short block installed in the car tonight. I'm using an 8 inch balancer, so some mild clearancing of the cross member was necessary. Nothing a couple light taps with a ball peen hammer didn't take care of.

3-12-09

Both TFS heads are on and torqued down.

3/25/09

Got flow information on the AFR heads. Intake is on the car, valve train is done. Hopefully, it will take it's first breath with the TFS heads this weekend.

4-13-09

Drove it around this weekend. I should have dyno numbers and track times by Sunday.

4/23/09

First round of dyno testing is done. Hopefully, I'll hit the drag strip and the dyno one more time before pulling it all apart to swap on the AFR heads.

6/16/09

Final testing is done with the TFS heads. The final numbers are:

Greatest RWHP achieved: 389
Best ET: 11.98
Best MPH: 119
Things to note: My best MPH was with a 150 Lb. passenger at a corrected elevation of ~2000 feet.

The AFR swap is under way.

8/31/09

AFR head swap is done and dyno'd. Track will happen over the labor day weekend, but the dyno results are 414 RWHP / 396 RWTQ. An increase of 25 RWHP and 23 RWTQ at the peak. The engine made more power all through the RPM band. Here is the chart, the AFR heads in red and the TFS heads in blue:

Resized Image

9/6/09

Went to Rockingham Dragway last night.

Details are:

8:57 PM - 9/5/09
60- 1.949
330- 5.256
1/8- 7.925 @ 90.27
1/4- 12.112 @ 118.13

Final ET and MPH with the AFR heads (after dialing in the tune and getting some seat time) is:

60- 1.67
1/4- 11.37 @ 122
Posted on: 2009/2/12 23:29
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Randyj75 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru Newb
MD
129 Posts
Member since:
2006/2/10 0:00



Offline
Interesting, can't wait for the results.

Randy
Posted on: 2009/2/13 1:55
_________________
'90 Corvette, M6,a few mods, more to come
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

1989GTA Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
61 Posts
Member since:
2008/12/25 1:38



Offline
Yes, very interesting. These are the kinds of tests I really look forward to. Thank you for doing it.
Posted on: 2009/2/13 2:12
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

bogus Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Grand Imperial Pooh-Bah
San Pedro, CA
20859 Posts
Member since:
2005/9/7 0:00



Offline
I await the results!!!
Posted on: 2009/2/13 3:00
_________________
The single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has taken place. - George Bernard Shaw

Education is the best tool to overcome irrational fear. - me

Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CentralCoaster Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
San Diego, CA
9454 Posts
Member since:
2007/10/28 0:00



Offline
I like that the price tag is the same.

Don't forget pictures!
Posted on: 2009/2/13 7:18
_________________
1985 Z51, ZF6
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

BrianCunningham Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Boston, MA for the most part :)
7763 Posts
Member since:
2007/12/30 0:00



Offline
Nice to see someone picking up the ball on this one.
Posted on: 2009/2/13 18:12
_________________
Polo Green 95 LT1 6-spd http://mysite.verizon.net/vzevcp74/
383 LT1/Vortech Supercharger/AFR heads/Rod end suspension/Penske-Hardbar dual rate coilovers/Wilwood 6pot brakes
NCCC Governor: http://BayStateCorvetteClub.com
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

BeachBum Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Master Guru
751 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/20 17:01



Offline
Looks like a fun test !

I do not know a lot about those particular Trick Flows, but in general, I've always thought of Trick Flow as a company well focused on the street/strip generation and a good cylinder head for our applications..... should be a competitive test.

I know those TFS 195's are advertised to flow in the mid 250's before porting.... so I guess it is a matter of how much work is done to them as to exactly how competitive they are.


Good Luck !
Posted on: 2009/2/13 19:47
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

88BlackZ51 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
481 Posts
Member since:
2008/10/2 8:40



Offline
Quote:

BeachBum wrote:
Looks like a fun test !

I do not know a lot about those particular Trick Flows, but in general, I've always thought of Trick Flow as a company well focused on the street/strip generation and a good cylinder head for our applications..... should be a competitive test.

I know those TFS 195's are advertised to flow in the mid 250's before porting.... so I guess it is a matter of how much work is done to them as to exactly how competitive they are.


Good Luck !




This gives you an idea of what the 195cc TFS heads flow as cast!


.200 lift(intake/exhaust) Trickflow-138/98
.300 lift(intake/exhaust) Trickflow-190/130
.400 lift(intake/exhaust) Trickflow-230/156
.500 lift(intake/exhaust) Trickflow-253/174
.600 lift(intake/exhaust) Trickflow-260/185
Posted on: 2009/2/14 1:05
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

tpi421vett Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Registered Vendor
Salt Lake City Utah
125 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/17 19:59



Offline
Thanks for the kind words Josh!

Anybody interested in some AFR's let me know.
Posted on: 2009/2/14 4:42
_________________
AFR Dealer, can sell at prices too low to advertise. 801-953-6391
08 C6 LS3,3LT,Z51,A6,NPP
91 vette,450ci, AFR 220, miniram,FAST, Crane 252/260 solid roller, 200 shot nos, ZF6, 4 link, 9", DA corrected to 1300 ft 9.65@145.xx
450ci now with AFR 235...
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
Pictures of the short block and TFS heads:

[IMG]http://i652.photobucket.com/albums/uu241/joshkinzey/DSCF0766.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i652.photobucket.com/albums/uu241/joshkinzey/DSCF0767.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i652.photobucket.com/albums/uu241/joshkinzey/DSCF0768.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i652.photobucket.com/albums/uu241/joshkinzey/DSCF0770.jpg[/IMG]

[IMG]http://i652.photobucket.com/albums/uu241/joshkinzey/DSCF0772.jpg[/IMG]
Posted on: 2009/2/14 6:02
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Randyj75 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru Newb
MD
129 Posts
Member since:
2006/2/10 0:00



Offline
Josh, do you have a part number for the TFS heads? How old are they? I am wondering if we are comparing apples to apples.

Randy

Summit Racing

Link to the Trick Flow heads.
Posted on: 2009/2/17 2:44
_________________
'90 Corvette, M6,a few mods, more to come
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
I posted that information in my first post:

Quote:
I'll be swapping between 2 sets of heads for the test:

TFS aluminum 195 CC heads, P/N TFS-30400006-CNC.
The heads have bee hive springs, 10 degree locks, and titanium retainers.
The heads have been lightly ported and decked by Lloyd Elliot.
Total retail for the heads with port work and upgraded springs is $2000.

AFR aluminum 195 CC heads competition ports, P/N AFR-1095. Nothing has been done to the heads, they will be bolted on as they come from AFR. Total retail for these heads is $2016.


The TFS heads are probably 18 months old or so.
Posted on: 2009/2/17 3:02
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
The first post has been edited with Trick Flow tech data, I've also included the data here. In the interest of full disclosure, I've copied and pasted the E-mail from the shop that tested the heads.

Quote:
Hi Josh,

They did arrive and I already have a bunch of information for you.

First off they are 100% ported….not just a bowl cleanup like you had alluded to. Guides are narrowed and necked downed nicely and this head had been ported from one end to the other. I might add it was done by someone who looked like they knew what they were doing and had a very neat hand (the walls were straight and the overall execution was certainly above average). The porting might not have been as obvious to you because the heads were glass-beaded when they were freshened disguising some of the finish sandroll marks that are clearly evident when you look closely.

Finished intake port volume 205 cc’s

Intake Flow

.200 @ 140
.300 @ 200
.400 @ 245
.500 @ 274
.550 @ 280
.600 @ 282

Exhaust port finished volume 76 cc’s

.200 @ 108
.300 @ 144
.400 @ 176
.500 @ 190
.600 @ 204

Combustion chamber volume is very small @ 57 cc’s (just under actually like 56.8 actually)
Posted on: 2009/2/19 3:07
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
Here's some better pictures of the TFS heads the shop sent me:

[IMG]http://i652.photobucket.com/albums/uu241/joshkinzey/TFS1.jpg[/IMG]

Resized Image

Resized Image
Posted on: 2009/2/19 3:22
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
Short block in the car:

Resized Image
Posted on: 2009/2/19 5:40
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

88BlackZ51 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
481 Posts
Member since:
2008/10/2 8:40



Offline
Those heads don't flow 2 bad. This should be a very interesting test.
Posted on: 2009/2/19 18:08
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

BrianCunningham Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Boston, MA for the most part :)
7763 Posts
Member since:
2007/12/30 0:00



Offline
It's nice that it will be a chassis dyno vs engine dyno

Some real #'s there.
Posted on: 2009/2/19 20:56
_________________
Polo Green 95 LT1 6-spd http://mysite.verizon.net/vzevcp74/
383 LT1/Vortech Supercharger/AFR heads/Rod end suspension/Penske-Hardbar dual rate coilovers/Wilwood 6pot brakes
NCCC Governor: http://BayStateCorvetteClub.com
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

rickreeves1 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru Newb
New Orleans
96 Posts
Member since:
2005/11/1 0:00



Offline




:goodpost:
Posted on: 2009/2/19 21:10
_________________
95-Lt1-auto-Polo-Conv, 125hp ZEX N2O dry, LE Cam 226/234 565/565 109LSA, Comp Pro Mag 1.6rr, Patriot Xtreme Springs, PCMFORLESS, K&N, AO Ram Air, 52mm TB, EM LT Headers, X-pipe, Meziere HD EWP, Vigil 2800, TransGo Shift Kit, Pro-Built Trans, 24lb SVO'...
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CentralCoaster Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
San Diego, CA
9454 Posts
Member since:
2007/10/28 0:00



Offline
Since the TFS port work was more than you expected, does that changes the out-the-door price tag on them?
Posted on: 2009/2/20 0:00
_________________
1985 Z51, ZF6
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

BeachBum Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Master Guru
751 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/20 17:01



Offline
Based upon the new information of the TF flow numbers, I'm thinking that the competition AFR 195's have an advantage of 10-20 hp due to increased flow..... but, with the small combustion chamber of the Trick Flows, compression will be up to close to a full point, which might steal some of that advantage..... but I dunno. (I assume the AFR's are the 64 cc chamber) What will your compression be with the two heads ?

No matter how you slice it, looks like a fun test....have fun with it !!
Posted on: 2009/2/20 3:10
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
When I bought the heads (used from someone on another forum) he sent me a receipt with them that said:

"Gasket match and chamber clean $300"

I don't really know if the porter did more than $300 worth of work or not. He charged the customer $300, without more information (hours involved, was their some kind of discount, etc...) we don't really have a choice other than to go by what is on the receipt. Maybe someone with some more knowledge of porting can look at the pictures and ball park the price that should be charged, but for right now the receipt is the only solid piece of information we have to go on.

I hate that port work might makes the test that much more insubstantial. I almost wish the TFS heads were out of the box so there were zero unknowns. Or atleast had work done to them that was absolutely quantifiable; things like the spring and retainer upgrade, new valves, etc... Stuff that has concrete price and value.
Posted on: 2009/2/20 23:15
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
Quote:

BeachBum wrote:
Based upon the new information of the TF flow numbers, I'm thinking that the competition AFR 195's have an advantage of 10-20 hp due to increased flow..... but, with the small combustion chamber of the Trick Flows, compression will be up to close to a full point, which might steal some of that advantage..... but I dunno. (I assume the AFR's are the 64 cc chamber) What will your compression be with the two heads ?


I'm not sure what I'm going to do about compression ratio right now. If I run a .030 gasket (which is what I want to do, I'm looking for a ~.045 quench) that puts the TFS heads at ~11.8:1. I'm not comfortable with a SCR that high. If I run a thicker head gasket the quench starts to suffer pretty badly.

What I'll probably do is use a .040 gasket on the TFS heads, which puts me at ~11.5:1. I don't like the compression that high, but I don't really see another option.

Then, I'll use a .028 gasket with 65CC chambers on the AFR heads for a final compression ratio of ~10.8:1.

I think that is realistically as close as I can make the 2 heads perform on the car. Any more head gasket on the TFS combo and the quench gets out of control, any less gasket or chamber on the AFR heads starts to put me in an area that I'm not comfortable with.

Quote:
No matter how you slice it, looks like a fun test....have fun with it !!


It is fun, but it's beating up my Visa card pretty bad. I was hoping for a little more support from the forum, but I guess it's rough out there for everyone.
Posted on: 2009/2/20 23:25
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

cuisinartvette Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Elite Guru
1782 Posts
Member since:
2005/9/16 0:00



Offline
Cleaning up (polishing Im assuning) the chambers wont really add any power but can help reduce hot apots and the possibility of pinging.
Posted on: 2009/2/21 4:58
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

88BlackZ51 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
481 Posts
Member since:
2008/10/2 8:40



Offline
It's too bad the CR won't be closer. I guess the only thing you could do I guess is mill a little off the AFR's.

Still be a fun test.
Posted on: 2009/2/21 10:37
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CFI-EFI Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Top of Utah
372 Posts
Member since:
2005/9/9 0:00



Offline
Quote:

Josh wrote:

I'm not sure what I'm going to do about compression ratio right now. If I run a .030 gasket (which is what I want to do, I'm looking for a ~.045 quench) that puts the TFS heads at ~11.8:1. I'm not comfortable with a SCR that high. If I run a thicker head gasket the quench starts to suffer pretty badly.

What I'll probably do is use a .040 gasket on the TFS heads, which puts me at ~11.5:1. I don't like the compression that high, but I don't really see another option.

Then, I'll use a .028 gasket with 65CC chambers on the AFR heads for a final compression ratio of ~10.8:1.

It sounds like you have the piston .015" down the hole. I wouldn't be happy with any more than a .045" quench, at the outside. How about doing some "unshrouding of the valves" in the TF heads to try to get the combustion chambers closer in size. Not only does this help the test, but it might make gathering parts a little easier too. Good luck. I wish I could help with the Visa problem, but I'm afraid I can't.

RACE ON!!!
Posted on: 2009/2/21 18:27
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

pr0zac Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Elite Guru
Pittsburgh
1045 Posts
Member since:
2008/10/20 23:28



Offline
what cam are you using???
Posted on: 2009/2/21 19:17
_________________
96 lt4. 357ci, 11:1, LE 226/232, LE2 LT4 heads, ported LT4 intake, EM Gladiator44, EM LT's, stock exhaust, NX kit.
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
The pistons are .015 below deck. I was shooting for a .040-045 quench, I don't trust the wrist pin/connecting rod enough to go much shorter than that.

I can't spend any more money on the TFS heads to open the chambers up. I would like to, but like you guys, I'm stretched pretty thin right now.

I plan to leave the AFR heads on the engine, so milling the AFR's to have a closer combustion chamber CC to the TFS really isn't an option. I'm looking for a final compression ratio of ~10.5:1, and a quench of ~.045, and that can't happen with a small chamber like the TFS heads. I'm not willing to sacrifice long term results for the comparison, especially since I'm picking up 99% of the tab. I was really hoping for some more forum support, but I guess it's tight for everyone right now.

Cam specs (and piston/deck information) was in the first post:

Quote:
Engine is a 383 with the following parts:

TPIS miniram with 1205 size ports
Eagle cast steel crank
Eagle forged rods, 6 inch, h-beam
SRP forged flat top pistons, .015 below deck
Chromoly rings
Comp Cam XFI cam P/N CCA-08-467-08 (230/236, .576/.57, 113 LSA, 56 degrees of overlap)
The rest of the engine is stock or new stock replacement parts.
Posted on: 2009/2/21 19:32
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

BeachBum Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Master Guru
751 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/20 17:01



Offline
I think despite the compression issues, it is still an interesting test..... I'm not sure, but I think in corner A: we have a 195 cc head that flows 300 cfm and will result in approxmiately 10.8-1 cr with its 64cc chamber. Whereas in corner B: we have a 205 cc head flowing 280 cfm and will result in approxmiately 11.6-1 cr with a 58 cc head.

Thus, one head is a little smaller, flows bigger but has almost a point less of a compression. It becomes a battle of flow vs compression so to speak. Will be interesting to see the effect.... I'm going to run it on my sim out of curiosity..... I don't know how accurate it will be, but its something to bench race about.

On financing for the test.....I've spent "a lot" of money over the last few months on my toy including $ 2500 to one of the manufacturers in this test.... but, I'll still throw a fifty or something into the hat if need be. Thats not a problem, but I will say, a test like this, you should be lobbying the very people who would benefit from this, which is potentially AFR or Trickflow or maybe the cylinder head porter......I'm betting the winner of a test like this could potentially see 10-20 cylinder heads sold over time based soley on the results of a test like this..... thats 10-20 thousand and would have warranted a few hundred dollar donation of some sort towards the free marketing exposure or at least you would think so.
Posted on: 2009/2/21 20:35
_________________
863 cubic inches of C4 & C6 muscle
C6 Corvette Z06 - Lemans Metallic Blue
C4 Corvette 436 - Pure Black

http://www.cardomain.com/ride/3933547 ... chevrolet-corvette/page-1
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CFI-EFI Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Top of Utah
372 Posts
Member since:
2005/9/9 0:00



Offline
Quote:

Josh wrote:
I can't spend any more money on the TFS heads to open the chambers up. I would like to, but like you guys, I'm stretched pretty thin right now.

I was thinking this might be something you could do yourself at home for little to no cost. Sorry, I wasn't trying to spend your money as so many people try to do. Also, I was thinking if you could increase the size of the chambers it would be better for your combination more than good for the comparo. Either way, best of luck.

RACE ON!!!

PS. I need a GOOD set of heads and a complete induction system. I am thinking of a single plane 4 bbl manifold drilled and fitted for injectors and a 4 bbl throttle body. Does anyone on here have any surplus parts?
Posted on: 2009/2/21 23:23
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
I don't have any porting experience, so I'm not comfortable taking a burr to the combustion chambers. I hadn't considered that you meant I could do it myself for little to no cash; communication barrier of the forum/Internet I suppose.

If you are looking for a good set of heads, I plan to have the TFS heads for sale in a month or so. I don't have any real surplus parts, but I do have some exhaust manifold gaskets you can have for shipping. I also have an LT1 intake that is part of an aborted conversion. The distributor hole has been messed up pretty bad, but someone with more time than I have might be able to make it work. Again, catch the shipping and it's yours. I have the LT1 fuel rails with -8 AN fittings TIG welded onto them that you can have as well.
Posted on: 2009/2/22 1:42
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

88BlackZ51 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
481 Posts
Member since:
2008/10/2 8:40



Offline
Quote:

BeachBum wrote:
I think despite the compression issues, it is still an interesting test..... I'm not sure, but I think in corner A: we have a 195 cc head that flows 300 cfm and will result in approxmiately 10.8-1 cr with its 64cc chamber. Whereas in corner B: we have a 205 cc head flowing 280 cfm and will result in approxmiately 11.6-1 cr with a 58 cc head.

Thus, one head is a little smaller, flows bigger but has almost a point less of a compression. It becomes a battle of flow vs compression so to speak. Will be interesting to see the effect.... I'm going to run it on my sim out of curiosity..... I don't know how accurate it will be, but its something to bench race about.

On financing for the test.....I've spent "a lot" of money over the last few months on my toy including $ 2500 to one of the manufacturers in this test.... but, I'll still throw a fifty or something into the hat if need be. Thats not a problem, but I will say, a test like this, you should be lobbying the very people who would benefit from this, which is potentially AFR or Trickflow or maybe the cylinder head porter......I'm betting the winner of a test like this could potentially see 10-20 cylinder heads sold over time based soley on the results of a test like this..... thats 10-20 thousand and would have warranted a few hundred dollar donation of some sort towards the free marketing exposure or at least you would think so.



Another good post by Beach. Josh, I certainly can't help you out with funding. I don't know what my 421 has cost me as of yet because I haven't added up the bills (better that way), but I am positive it's more then most would be willing to spend. Plus a bought a ZF6 to boot. I wish I could help with some funding, but I am straped!

Beach. I am looking forward to seeing what your sim spits out in regards to tq, and hp. Being that the TFS has a little bigger port, and has more compression to work with, I don't think the winner will win by a landslide.
Posted on: 2009/2/22 11:29
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CFI-EFI Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Top of Utah
372 Posts
Member since:
2005/9/9 0:00



Offline
Quote:

Josh wrote:
I don't have any porting experience, so I'm not comfortable taking a burr to the combustion chambers. I hadn't considered that you meant I could do it myself for little to no cash; communication barrier of the forum/Internet I suppose.
The break down in communications was mine. I didn't specify, plus I ASS-U-MEd. Unshrouding the valves shouldn't take the knowledge of a skilled head porter, but if you aren't comfortable, that's that.


Quote:

Josh wrote:
If you are looking for a good set of heads, I plan to have the TFS heads for sale in a month or so. I don't have any real surplus parts, but I do have some exhaust manifold gaskets you can have for shipping. I also have an LT1 intake that is part of an aborted conversion. The distributor hole has been messed up pretty bad, but someone with more time than I have might be able to make it work. Again, catch the shipping and it's yours. I have the LT1 fuel rails with -8 AN fittings TIG welded onto them that you can have as well.
I am interested in all of that, but mostly the heads. I will have to go back and reread all that you've written to get a fresh handle on just what they are. I'm not sure, yet, if I am going to need heads, but keep me in mind and see what you think you need for them. Thanks,

RACE ON!!!
Posted on: 2009/2/22 19:08
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

bogus Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Grand Imperial Pooh-Bah
San Pedro, CA
20859 Posts
Member since:
2005/9/7 0:00



Offline
This is getting interesting.

I can't wait to see the end results. Any time table?

For those of you who are still interested in donating to help Josh defer costs, my email is abbogus@yahoo.com.

I am holding all funds in my paypal acct and will forward it to Josh when the time is right.

Currently, we have ONE donator!

CentralCoaster has fronted $10.00.

If we all do that, we will get Josh a few hundred towards the dyno tests.

Let's get emailing!!! I will keep a separate thread with detailed accounting of the donations. It will be very public. Not to intimidate others into donating, but to keep this on the up and up.

Andy
Posted on: 2009/2/22 20:35
_________________
The single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has taken place. - George Bernard Shaw

Education is the best tool to overcome irrational fear. - me

Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

BeachBum Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Master Guru
751 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/20 17:01



Offline
88black,

I haven't had a chance to run the simulator yet, but I suspect the power will be fairly close to what Wes got out of his 395 sbc..... probably a hair more HP out of Josh's motor, but a hair less torque mostly due to the Miniram.

But, not sure... will run it later in the week.
Posted on: 2009/2/23 4:45
_________________
863 cubic inches of C4 & C6 muscle
C6 Corvette Z06 - Lemans Metallic Blue
C4 Corvette 436 - Pure Black

http://www.cardomain.com/ride/3933547 ... chevrolet-corvette/page-1
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

dan0617 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Tyrone, PA
1260 Posts
Member since:
2007/12/30 0:00



Offline
Have you checked the dynamic cr with the combos? I wouldn't be afraid of 11.8 as long as your dyamic is good. My build is together and running and has made a handful of WOT runs. It is 11.2 scr, 8.9 dcr. Running a .035 quench with stock 400 rods (with arp bolts) and crank and speed pro forged pistons in a 350 block to make a 383. This is with afr 195 eliminators. I so far have heard no detonation and no pistons bumping heads and I've turned it to 7000 rpms a couple of times trying to get the governor sorted out. Not going to do that anymore but I would not be afraid of a .035 quench and a high dcr. The tighter quench distance might very well make up for the higher scr and give you no problems at all. Just don't guess at it, find an online dynamic cr calculator and input ALL the information it needs. Take the time to get the proper information, then do some research. Again, with a good tight quench you can run dcr in the high 8's or possibly low 9's on high octane pump gas and a good combustion chamber design. Don't worry about the scr, it is what it is and it doesn't matter so long as the dcr is good.
Posted on: 2009/2/23 18:40
_________________
´89 Vert, 383, 230/236 cam, AFR 195's, LT Headers, HSR intake, 2800 stall, Zex 200 shot, ET Street Radials, tune by me. Runs were with D36 3.07's.
On spray, 10.55 @ 132.78, 1.55 60 ft.
On motor, 12.08 @ 113.15, 1.66 60 ft.
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CFI-EFI Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Top of Utah
372 Posts
Member since:
2005/9/9 0:00



Offline
Quote:

dan0617 wrote:
Running a .035 quench with stock 400 rods (with arp bolts) and crank and speed pro forged pistons in a 350 block to make a 383.

That is an interesting engine parts combination. Although I have mentioned it to several people, I don't believe I've seen anyone using the short 5.565" rods, before. Those rods allow the use of more readily available (and sometimes cheaper) 350 pistons. Even the "Chevrolet Power" book specs OKs the .035" piston to head dimension. I have been thinking of pushing that, a little.

RACE ON!!!
Posted on: 2009/2/24 1:58
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
Here is what I think I am going to do:

.040 head gasket on the TFS heads, that puts me at ~11.5 SCR and ~8.9 DCR with a .055 quench. I think the quench is pretty wide for that much compression (both static and dynamic) but I don’t really have a choice.

I'll have the AFR heads milled to 60 CC. I’ll use a .028 gasket which will put me at 11.4 SCR and 8.85 DCR with a .043 quench.

If that sounds good to you guys, I’ll order the gaskets tomorrow and get going on putting it together.
Posted on: 2009/2/24 3:40
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

tpi421vett Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Registered Vendor
Salt Lake City Utah
125 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/17 19:59



Offline
I think that will work well. It will make the compression comparable, and help make good power. Keep in mind a typical L98 had a piston .025 in the hole with a .055 gasket=.080 quench. So both of these are far better than stock.
Posted on: 2009/2/24 4:21
_________________
AFR Dealer, can sell at prices too low to advertise. 801-953-6391
08 C6 LS3,3LT,Z51,A6,NPP
91 vette,450ci, AFR 220, miniram,FAST, Crane 252/260 solid roller, 200 shot nos, ZF6, 4 link, 9", DA corrected to 1300 ft 9.65@145.xx
450ci now with AFR 235...
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

BeachBum Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Master Guru
751 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/20 17:01



Offline
To liven this dyno test up, I think we should have a poll shootout on the dyno results.... closest to guess the results, wins a guru hat or something fun like that.

Who's dyno and what type of dyno will this be on ?
Posted on: 2009/2/26 23:12
_________________
863 cubic inches of C4 & C6 muscle
C6 Corvette Z06 - Lemans Metallic Blue
C4 Corvette 436 - Pure Black

http://www.cardomain.com/ride/3933547 ... chevrolet-corvette/page-1
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CentralCoaster Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
San Diego, CA
9454 Posts
Member since:
2007/10/28 0:00



Offline
I'm presuming dynojet for repeatability sake?
Posted on: 2009/2/26 23:30
_________________
1985 Z51, ZF6
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

88BlackZ51 Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
481 Posts
Member since:
2008/10/2 8:40



Offline
Quote:

BeachBum wrote:
To liven this dyno test up, I think we should have a poll shootout on the dyno results.... closest to guess the results, wins a guru hat or something fun like that.

Who's dyno and what type of dyno will this be on ?


I have thought about this as well. I would be fun to see who is the closest.
Posted on: 2009/2/27 0:12
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
All the dyno testing will be on a Dynojet 224 at Mayhem Motorsports in Raleigh, NC.

I plan to have video of the dyno sessions and track time.
Posted on: 2009/2/27 2:37
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
Transmission is back in the car, and I got the TFS head back from the shop that flow tested it.

Hopefully, the car will take it's first breath this coming weekend.
Posted on: 2009/3/2 13:53
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
My help got food poisoning this weekend, so I was solo. I still got a fair amount done. The C-beam and drive shaft are in and the passenger side TFS head is on and torqued down. More reports as the week progresses.
Posted on: 2009/3/9 3:07
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

CentralCoaster Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
San Diego, CA
9454 Posts
Member since:
2007/10/28 0:00



Offline
Posted on: 2009/3/9 16:34
_________________
1985 Z51, ZF6
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
Both TFS heads are on and torqued down. All the ground on the drivers side of the motor are hooked up. I'm hoping to knock out the valve train this weekend. As long as I don't have to order pushrods, I should be able to get the intake and everything on the motor this weekend.
Posted on: 2009/3/13 3:01
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Calm Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Vancouver, Canada
608 Posts
Member since:
2007/12/27 0:00



Offline
Posted on: 2009/3/13 5:23
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Calm Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Senior Guru
Vancouver, Canada
608 Posts
Member since:
2007/12/27 0:00



Offline
Josh,
How you gunna be for parts and dyno costs? The donations holding up?
Posted on: 2009/3/13 5:25
_________________
1995 Forged 385 ZF6 227/234 1.6 FIC30# MSD BBK SS SLP Bullets X-Pipe DynoMax
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

Josh Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Guru
Raleigh, NC
666 Posts
Member since:
2008/1/1 0:00



Offline
The donations right now are at about $150, plus some parts here and there.

The head gaskets for the TFS heads were right at $100 shipped, so that only leaves about $50 for fluids, silicone, and dyno time.

I figure the extra $50 will cover the antifreeze, oil, filter, silicone, and maybe the intake gasktes. At this point I'm on my own for the dyno time and what ever misc. crap I'll need.

I don't think the donations are done or anything, I'm pretty sure some more people will donate as I get closer to completing the tests. Thanks for asking about it. You can see the list of people that have helped out in the donation thread Andy made:

http://www.corvette-guru.com/modules/ ... php?topic_id=7380&forum=1
Posted on: 2009/3/13 19:27
_________________
"Have ya paid your dues, Jack?" "Yessir, the check is in the mail." - Jack Burton
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

tpi421vett Re: Air Flow Research (AFR) 195's VS Trick Flow Specialties (TFS) 195's - Test within
Registered Vendor
Salt Lake City Utah
125 Posts
Member since:
2008/11/17 19:59



Offline
Hey josh, can't wait to see how it turns out!
Posted on: 2009/3/14 4:49
_________________
AFR Dealer, can sell at prices too low to advertise. 801-953-6391
08 C6 LS3,3LT,Z51,A6,NPP
91 vette,450ci, AFR 220, miniram,FAST, Crane 252/260 solid roller, 200 shot nos, ZF6, 4 link, 9", DA corrected to 1300 ft 9.65@145.xx
450ci now with AFR 235...
Transfer the post to other applications Transfer

(1) 2 3 »
You can view topic.
You cannot start a new topic.
You cannot reply to posts.
You cannot edit your posts.
You cannot delete your posts.
You cannot add new polls.
You cannot vote in polls.
You cannot attach files to posts.
You cannot post without approval.

[Advanced Search]


CorvetteForum.guru is independently owned and operated. This site is not associated with or financially supported by General Motors.

Copyright 2008-2015 CorvetteForum.guru

CorvetteForum.guru is a Guru Garage Site (Coming Soon!)

If you have any questions about our site, please contact us at Andy@corvetteforum.guru.

Powered by XOOPS 2.56 Copyright 2001-2014 www.xoops.org

Hosted by GoDaddy.com.